Hemingway Gets into the Ring
Herbert Kuhner
Here’s Hemingway the pugilist: “I started out very quiet and I beat Mr. Turgenev. Then I trained hard and I beat Mr. De Maupassant. I’ve fought two draws with Stendhal, and I think I had an edge in the last one. But nobody’s going to get me in any ring with Mr. Tolstoy unless I’m crazy or I keep getting better.”
- Ernest Hemingway, The New Yorker, May 13,1950Believe it or not folks, this statement came from a man of letters, who was a Nobel Laureate, to boot!
He was sort of right - as far as fisticuffs are concerned. But I’d give him even more than he gives himself. He could have knocked out three of the four in a genuine boxing ring. I’m not so sure about Maupassant, who was quite an athlete; I’d place my bets on him.
The bookmaker may be the right address for bets on boxing, but it’s the wrong address for literary evaluation, since the matter of winners and losers is completely theoretical.
Incidentally, Tolstoy made comparisons too. He thought that Shakespeare was dwarf compared to him, and another genius he put down was the great Leonid Andreyev.
Literary merit is always a debatable quality. An author shouldn’t be asked to blow his own horn, and if he blows voluntarily, he’s invariably supercilious. Rating an author is the business of the reader and the critic. Only a fool or a tyro would publicly compare himself to others of the trade. When start to compare, you’re bound to lose.
Let me tack this on! I love Maupassant more than I can say. What would I be without him? And by saying that, I win.
Posted: July 24th, 2010 under Polemics, Text.
Comments: none
German
Spanish
French
Italian
Portuguese
Dutch
Greek
Japanese
Korean
Russian
Chinese
